Apparently it was good enough to recall 2015, the year called the greatest of the century. Ha!
Honestly, it gets praised every year, so I can't make sense of it anymore!
This is the Beaujolais Nouveau note I wrote on November 16, 2017. “This year” therefore means 2017 here. Reading that description alongside contemporary tasting reports offers a way to pick out words that actually help us imagine a particular bottle.
The description in my 2017 post
This was the description I included at the time:
The original description praised the balance of acidity, fruit and tannin, then compared 2017’s richness with the acclaimed 2015 vintage while adding liveliness and elegance. The original post did not retain the first speaker’s identity, so I cannot attribute that assessment to a named expert or organization.

The image also says Beaujolais Nouveau 2017 and November 16 release. Mercian's 2017 release announcement likewise gives November 16 as the release date for the French new wines.
My reaction was the amused confusion at the start: it seems to get praised every year. This was a response to the description, rather than a verdict from tasting and ranking the vintages myself.
Superlatives and descriptions of taste
Read carefully, the phrase calling a vintage the greatest of the century refers to 2015. The sentence says 2017 recalls its richness; it does not say 2017 surpasses it. Keeping track of the direction of that comparison helps when the language is emphatic.
The sentence also calls acidity, fruit character and tannins balanced. It does not, on its own, establish how strong each one is. As a hypothetical example, someone looking for pronounced acidity would still want a more specific description of the acidity beyond “well balanced.”
The strength of the praise and the description of the taste answer different questions. Looking separately at the previous-year comparison, the sensory words and the wine's name gives us more to work with than “apparently another amazing year.”
Different bottles and different tasters in the same year
Mynavi News's 2017 sommelier tasting describes five wines separately. It notes fruit-like acidity and bitterness for the standard Georges Duboeuf, and deeper acidity and more tannin for the Villages. Even within one producer and vintage, identifying the particular bottle matters.
The Director's View blog's tasting record evaluates the balance of acidity, fruit character and astringency in Seijo Ishii's Cave de Julienas. The writer also says that one bottle is insufficient to judge the year as a whole. That qualification makes the scope of the personal verdict clearer.
The personal wine-tasting notebook finds the 2017 Georges Duboeuf easy to drink, while expressing reservations about its quality as a wine. Ease of drinking and a particular writer's high rating are not necessarily the same thing either.
If two accounts seem to disagree, first match the wine name and year, then look at what each one is praising. Those concrete details make the annual acclaim easier to read when your first reaction is, “So are they all good every year?”
The Beaujolais Nouveau product link included in the original post











