Sarcocaulon herrei, known as 竜骨城 in Japanese. Its winter-growing side was really getting started—look at all those leaves!
This is the photo from September 2018 when I wrote that. Fine leaves changed the impression of the rugged trunk. Watching the leaves after summer gave me something to look forward to as the weather became cooler.
The contrast between the rugged trunk and fine leaves
The photo shows a spiny trunk extending sideways, with small green leaves at different points along it. More foliage made the contrast between the hard-looking trunk and delicate leaves easier to enjoy.
isla del pescado’s species account explains that leaf stalks remain after the leaves drop and become woody spines. New leaves and old leaf stalks can therefore be parts of the same branch’s changing appearance over time.

Winter-growing is a clue to cooler-season activity
LOVEGREEN, using the name Monsonia herrei with Sarcocaulon as the former genus, describes summer leaf drop and dormancy followed by autumn sprouting. Tanikuchan’s Monsonia guide also describes growth in cooler weather.
Winter-growing does not mean that every winter condition suits the plant. LOVEGREEN warns about strong cold winds and frost, and isla del pescado describes leaf damage in cold winds too. Autumn sprouting, deep-winter cold, and spring growth should be considered with the plant’s leaves and location rather than treated as one identical season.
Someone commented that their plant had not slept either
After I posted to Instagram, someone commented that their Sarcocaulon herrei had not gone to sleep either.
I wondered whether, depending on the environment, a plant called winter-growing might retain leaves and lose only some of them. That was my possibility at the time. The other person’s location and watering are not recorded, but the comment made it interesting to watch the individual plant rather than assume that all leaves must disappear every summer.
Compare new growth, not only the month
For example, a plant retaining leaves in autumn and a plant producing new leaves are not necessarily showing the same change. Photos of the same branch taken at intervals could help distinguish old leaves from new ones appearing at the tip or along the trunk. This is an example for a future observation, not a measured photo sequence from 2018.
Care explanations are also more specific when read beyond the calendar. Isla del pescado describes gradually resuming watering as cooler weather brings new leaves. That calls for comparing whether leaves are actually appearing, whether the soil is dry, and whether hot weather is continuing. My delighted “really getting started!” in 2018 began with noticing the leaves themselves.
Posted September 4, 2018 at 9:11 AM. This post was originally published from Instagram.
#sarcocaulon #sarcocaulonherrei #サルコカウロン #サルコカウロンヘレー #竜骨城 #多肉植物 #植物 #多肉 #caudex #塊根植物 #ボタニカルライフ #コーデックス #塊根 #plants #観葉植物 #植物のある暮らし #緑のある暮らし #グリーンのある暮らし #日常の風景 #succulents
Sources
- LOVEGREEN: How to grow Monsonia herrei
- isla del pescado: Sarcocaulon herrei
- Tanikuchan: Monsonia (Sarcocaulon), characteristics and care
The original September 6, 2018 article has been expanded by separating the owner's observation from the seasonal descriptions in three sources. The photo, Instagram link, comment, and cautious possibility about leaves remaining have been kept as part of the original record.










